as i stare at the backside of a familiar door, i see its knob turn, the hinges creek, and once halfway open, i greet a close friend as he walks past the door into the room. i’ve had many intelligent and enlightening conversations over the years with this guy, in this very room--conversations that have shaped our beliefs and our behaviors, conversations that have sent us many years down roads that are we are still traveling--and in this sense, this room is like a sacred swamp.
i've noticed that most theological discussions take the form of a tennis match; when it is one person’s turn to discuss a topic, he tosses his opinion high above his head, and right at the peak of its intellectual height, the opinion is sent hurling through the air into the court of the other in a way that (ideally) makes it impossible to interact with. i enjoy playing tennis and the truth is, i can compete at a relatively high skill level. i’ve played tennis with this friend before. we’ve both won our share of games and have had a colorful history of competition; but these days, i’ve more or less retired my racket. when you hit someone in the face or the crotch with a powerful volley shot, it can be pretty amusing at first. but after repeated occurrences, if you care at all for your friend/competitor, you’ll find yourself wishing there were a better way to prove/win the point. there is plenty i don't know about tennis, but of this i am certain: no one likes to get hit in the crotch.
i would prefer my theological discussions with others to look more like a game of chess; but instead of aiming to put the other into intellectual check, i’d rather move the pieces around the board and talk about why things are playing out the way they are. if the result of careful reasoning and conflicting paradigms is a checkmate in the discussion, the defeat is highly significant as an observation but pretty frustrating and isolating as a value statement.
though i prefer to play chess with my friend, he brought his racket with him today and he enters the room with one hell of a serve. i scramble for my racket and begin a match that i quickly see is shaking my Faith in no uncertain terms. i find myself returning balls that i never knew i had the skills for and for a while i succeed in deflecting the competition. but my friend has been training hard for this encounter and by mid-match i am on my heals more than my toes. i marvel at his new strokes and wonder what it would feel like to hit a ball the way he is. the game offers no sign of relent and i begin to accept that this theological competition is going to result in either a loss for me, or, at best, a draw. but a draw at tennis with this particular friend is more of a victory for him than anything… tennis isn’t even his sport of choice. as we continue our athletic dialogue, i grow spiritually fatigued and feel increasingly ill-equipped for the match. i start to notice how hard it is for me to breathe and maneuver around the court, so in desperation, i ask my friend if we could pick this game up at a later time. he agrees to let the game go unfinished, but as he exits the room, we both know that he is leaving “the victor”. once he has shut the door, i am reminded why i had meant to retire my racket.
it seems like everybody these days are up for an evenly matched competition of convictions, but all i can think about is how nice it would be to take the court with someone interested in just hitting the ball back and forth for the sake of exercise and enjoying one another’s company. and should the casual banter degrade to the desire to win, then both would readily acknowledge the sentiment, put down their rackets, and go grab a drink or a bite together. there is something eternally significant about drink and food shared among friends.
with my friend out of the room, the ceiling begins to weigh down on me, descnending in a way that is easier felt than seen. once again, i am aware of my shallow, constricted breathing.
and as i look again at the backside of a familiar door, i see a missed meal at the expense of theological athletics, and i begin to weep.
